2    ARTICLES VERIFIED AND SCHEDULED FOR PUBLICATION Published June 2009
Sound Instruction - Ready to Use Classroom Practice     Volume II     ISBN 0-9709895-1-2
Book Editors: Melinda R. Pierson, PhD, Kristin K. Stang, PhD Ben Varner, PhD


Preface - 5
Sound Instruction:  Ready to Use Classroom Practice Volume II is just the beginning 
of a collaboration between researchers and practitioners across the country and the
 world.  Educators from Hong Kong to Minnesota and from Nevada to Scotland were 
invited to participate in the dissemination of their research through this collection
of qualitative papers, case studies, and research projects. This collection of work 
provides an important framework for a discussion of key issues in instruction.

The content in Sound Instruction:  Ready to Use Classroom Practice Volume II focuses 
on three areas of education that are of critical importance to all aspects of the 
field:  assessment, consultation/collaboration, and online learning.  In this volume 
a group of authors address a wide variety of sub-topics within these areas.  It is 
our hope that this book can be used as a resource for practitioners in the field of 
education, for college students training to be educators, and for community members 
seeking greater knowledge about educational assessment, consultation/collaboration, 
and online teaching and learning. In addition, many of the submissions allow for an 
examination of student and teacher perceptions regarding these valuable topics. The 
articles selected for inclusion in this collection include those that we felt make 
an important contribution to furthering our understanding of sound instruction. 	

The focus on assessment at all levels of education has increased dramatically over 
the past several years as accountability and reporting have become more data-driven.  
From determining appropriate academic levels of students to determining effective 
teaching practices, to the analysis of the validity and reliability of specific 
assessment tools, proper assessment is necessary. As such, many different aspects of 
educational assessment are covered in this chapter. Sound Instruction:  Ready to Use 
Classroom Practice Volume II begins with this chapter since assessment provides a 
key foundation for all instruction and program analysis. The selected articles 
include both formative and summative assessment as well as discussions of both 
classroom-based and self-assessment techniques. Many articles in the following 
chapters also address issues of assessment, but this chapter is specifically 
designed with a collection of work for which the assessment was the primary focus. 

A total of nine articles have been selected for inclusion in this chapter on 
assessment, and while the topics covered are not exhaustive, we feel that they do 
address many important aspects of sound assessment practice and analysis. We 
acknowledge that the process of assessment is important to the examination of 
student, teacher, and program outcomes. Furthermore, it is important to note that 
assessment can be used to measure outcomes while also being used to guide teaching 
or to examine beliefs and perceptions. If used efficiently and effectively, 
assessment can be a valuable tool. Therefore, it is our hope that you find ideas, 
procedures, and practices in this chapter that will help strengthen your use of the 
assessment process.

The second and largest chapter in this text includes articles that address research 
on consultation and collaboration among professionals, international collaboration 
projects, partnerships between schools and universities, and analysis of specific 
elements within a specific course. It is not a surprise that this constitutes the 
largest section of this text, with seventeen invited submissions because collaborative
relationships are of critical importance to successful instruction. Included among 
these rich and diverse studies are articles that focus on preparing teachers for 
collaboration. Addressing collaboration reform is highlighted in several different 
sections of this chapter.  In addition, research on specific methods to consult in a 
business environment, collaboration in inclusive classrooms, and an analysis of 
different models of co-teaching are also included.  We hope that as you search for 
effective ways to provide instruction, to improve student learning and enhance 
program outcomes, you look to collaborative and consultative relationships. 

The final chapter in this text includes a selection of work that focuses on online 
learning and technology. We are pleased that Dr. Ben Varner has joined us as the 
chapter editor for this valuable collection of work. Sound Instruction:  Ready to 
Use Classroom Practice Volume II ends with this focus since online learning and 
instruction has become one of the aspects of instruction that is quickly changing 
and becoming of increased importance at all levels of education. As more and more 
learning is taking place within an online experience, it becomes critical that 
educators examine not only the best practices in online instruction but also 
participate in program evaluation of online programs, examine student perception of 
online learning as well as course design and student and teacher expectations. 

In this chapter you will find valuable information that will help guide your future 
online learning and teaching experiences. Dr. Varner describes these submissions by 
stating that “Web-based instructional delivery has resulted in an explosion of 
‘online learning’ initiatives, technological innovations in education, and creative 
uses of the Internet. This focus is on ways of delivering instruction through 
asynchronous or synchronous methods either through online courses or by ‘hybrid’ 
or ‘blended’ courses.” Therefore, the selected articles expand on this instructional 
delivery.

We hope that Sound Instruction:  Ready to Use Classroom Practice Volume II can be 
used in a variety of ways. First, it should serve as a resource for faculty and 
staff as they use assessment, consultation/collaboration, and online learning in 
their instruction of students and analysis of practice. We do not think that these 
three topics occur in isolation---but for the purpose of this text, we offer the 
works as small collections or chapters.  Sometimes the lines between the topics 
blur since many articles present a study or concept that may overlap another topic 
in this volume. Above all, the information will hopefully serve as a guide to 
improve practices in these areas. Secondly, it is hoped that the collection of 
articles can be used as a text for pre-service and in-service coursework for those 
who desire to improve their craft by delivering sound instruction.  

Finally, this volume of Sound Instruction could not have been published without 
the dedicated educators who are conducting research and writing in the areas of 
assessment, consultation and collaboration, and online learning. Their expertise, 
work, experience and thoughts combine to make this text a useful tool.  This volume, 
then, is the ultimate collaborative endeavor. 

Melinda Pierson, Ph.D.  Professor
Department of Special Education
California State University Fullerton

Kristin Stang, Ph.D.   Associate Professor
Department of Special Education
California State University Fullerton

Ben Varner, Ph.D.  Professor
School of English Language and Literature
University of Northern Colorado



Assessment - 7
Our probing measurement of the learning process in all its diverse forms and 
contexts has enabled significant advances in educational theory and practice at 
all levels and in all fields. Effective assessment can play a vital role in 
appropriately placing students, diagnosing learning problems and progress, 
improving and enriching teacher performance, and in achieving and maintaining 
academic standards. Assessment can be at the level of the individual learner, 
the class, the institution, or the educational system as a whole. 

In addition, research demonstrates that the process of assessment is important to 
the examination of student, teacher, and program outcomes. Assessment can be used 
to measure outcomes while being used to guide teaching or examine beliefs and 
perceptions. Assessment is a valuable tool if used efficiently and effectively. 
Various procedures for assessing students, classrooms, teachers, schools, and 
programs are presented in the following chapter.  

Formative assessment, or that ongoing assessment that drives instruction is examined 
in three articles, whereas strategic assessment design is examined in others. Student 
practices in assessment are examined as well as challenges to assessment and
 particular models of assessment practice. 

A variety of different articles that focus upon these important assessment issues 
is included.  Other topics selected for this chapter include service learning and 
self-assessment. We hope that you will find the topics and projects examined by 
authors in this issue valuable in your use of effective assessment across a variety 
of learners and settings.

Challenges to Effective Assessment of Learning  /  8
Peer Assessment and Role Play: A Winning Alliance  /  14
Assessment Strategies as Formative Evaluation  /  19
Self-Grading for Formative Assessment  in PBL  /  24
Validity of the DIBELS Oral Reading Fluency Test  /  29
Practice and Challenges of Formative Assessment  /  35
Self-Assessment: Grading or Knowing?  /  40
Service Learning and Student Performance  /  45
A Model for Comprehensive Assessment in the College Classroom  /  50



Consultation and Collaboration - 55
Educators are no longer able to work in isolation from one another. K-12 schools and 
universities embrace the need for collaborative efforts among and between faculty 
and staff.  Interdisciplinary collaboration, in which faculty from various 
disciplines work with one another to promote connections between otherwise separate 
curricula, is one of the ways in which educators are making these efforts. This 
chapter includes a collection of articles examining these important issues.

Several articles present collaboration as it relates directly to teachers. These 
include studies that examine both practice and attitude as we examine collaborative 
and consultative activities. Some key pieces include Lessons on Literacy: An 
Experience in Co-Teaching and Telling Stories of our Collaborative Practice.  We 
hope that from these examinations of practice you can improve your own collaborative 
and consultative experiences. Other investigations addressed specific successful 
program analysis such as (1) School Collaboration Research: Successes and 
Difficulties, (2) Collaborative Voices: One University-School Models and (3) 
Business Liaison Collaboration: A Case Study. These types of analyses are beneficial 
to consider since we all are challenged to increase accountability in practice, and 
this is best served through appropriate analysis and assessment of our collaborative 
and consultative processes. 

Additional articles are included that address issues in the field of professional 
development and teacher attitudes and include Improving Teachers’ Assessment 
Knowledge and Successful Preparation of Teachers of Students with Disabilities.  
Others clearly identify the overlap between the issues presented in this volume and 
examine a combination of assessment, collaboration and online experiences. 

These are just a few examples of the wide range of topics on collaboration that are 
included within this chapter. It is our hope that you enjoy this engaging issue full 
of useful, practical, and creative ways to better integrate effective consultation 
and collaboration into your and your students’ educational experiences.

Collaborating for Information Literacy  /  56
Global Competency: An Interdisciplinary Approach  /  61
A Partnership for Literacy  /  68
Impact of Administrative Placement upon Programs  /  73
Detective Fiction and Forensics in Collaboration  /  78
Lit circles, collaboration and student interest  /  84
Business Liaison Collaboration: A Case Study  /  91
Lessons on Literacy: An Experience in Co-Teaching  /  97
Telling stories of our collaborative practice  /  103
A Winning Combination:  Collaboration in Inclusion  /  108
School Collaboration Research: Successes and Difficulties  /  113
“Does One Size Fit All?”: Culturally Responsive Collaboration  /  118
Two New Evaluation Instruments for Collaboration  /  123
Collaborative Voices: One University-School Model  /  128
Interpretive Processes in Collaborative Research  /  133
Successful Preparation of Teachers of Students with Disabilities  /  138
Improving Classroom Assessment Practices: A Collaborative Approach  /  144



Online Learning and Technology - 149
It may seem odd to have a combination of “Assessment and Consultation” along with 
“Online Learning” within the same volume.  But on reflection, the reader will see 
the correlation between the topics.  Online discussion has grown increasingly 
important, especially as it relates to assessment and consultation among students 
and scholars.  Learning has taken place—and the venue has been largely online.

This volume will address both subjects with insight.  We have contributions by 
teaching colleagues which address assessment and consultation along with online 
instruction.  My co-editors, Melinda Pierson and Kristin Stang, will provide a 
summary of the “Assessment and Consultation” articles; I will do the same for the 
“Online Learning” submissions.

As Pierson and Stang describe their topic, “Educators are no longer able to work in 
isolation from one another. K-12 schools and universities are embracing the need for 
collaborative efforts among and between faculty. Interdisciplinary collaboration, in 
which faculty from various disciplines work with one another to promote connections 
between otherwise separate curricula, is one of the ways in which educators are 
making these efforts. Another example of collaboration is that between faculty at the 
K-12 level and university faculty. In other instances, the need for consultation 
emerges; consultation has traditionally inferred a triadic relationship between the 
person with expertise as the consultant, a consultee, and a client, but the 
emergence of collaborative consultation provides a sense of parity between 
consultant and consultee.”

The online venue provides for much of this collaboration.  Amany Salah’s article 
titled “Cooperative Learning in the Online Classroom” discusses students working 
amongst themselves in cooperation, and Jennifer McLean suggests ways to promote 
collaboration among faculty in her article “Promoting Faculty Commitment to Distance 
Learning.”  Laura Bolin Carroll’s article “Virtual Citizens: Online Service Learning” 
discusses the importance of service-learning and writing.  Rochelle Matthews-Somerville 
shows us the differing perspectives of students in online instruction in her article 
“Distance Learning: College Students’ Perspectives.”

In addition to the articles referred to above, there are several others focusing on 
learning and collaboration via distributed education.  This volume will provide a 
number of excellent resources for scholars of assessment, consultation, and online 
learning.

This volume was produced by the hard work of my co-editors, Kristin Stang and 
Melinda Pierson, along with the contributions of their colleagues.  The publisher, 
Rapid Intellect, has done a superb job of publication, creating a volume which we 
can all be proud of.  Finally, I wish to thank my online colleagues who are forging 
ahead in this new venue of instruction.  I learned much from them; I hope you do too.

On-Line Courses: Recommendations for Teachers  /  150
Virtual Design Based Research  /  155
Student Expectations for Distance Education  /  160
Re-envisioning Asynchronous Communication  /  166
Forgotten Alumni: Online Learners as Donors  /  171
Promoting Faculty Commitment to Distance Learning  /  176
Student Perceptions of a Hybrid Course  /  182
Reversing Roles to Create an Online Course  /  187
Virtual Citizens: Online Service Learning  /  193
Cooperative learning in the online classroom  /  198
Online Strategies for Military Cadets   /   204
Environmental Factors in Small Business Computing  /  209
Distance Learning: College Students’ Perspectives  /  214
Practical Guide for Facilitating Online Courses  /  219


Author Index - 224
Aberasturi,   Ruth  /  29
Aberasturi,  Suzanne  /  29
Amerman,  Tracy  /  108
Arendale, David R.  /  73
Ayala, Emiliano C.  /  118
Bath,   Barbara B.  /  144
Bennett,  B. Cole  /  193
Black, Erik W.  /   171
Boylan, Helen M.  /  78
Burstein,  Joyce  /  128
Carroll,  Laura Bolin  /  193
Choy,  Doris  /56
Chun, LO Yiu  /  35
Clemons,  Angel  /  91
Cox,  Fannie  /  91
Creamer,  Elizabeth  /  133
Cyboran, Vince  /  40 
Davis,   Jeanne  /  138
Dawson,  Kara  /  171
DelVecchio,  Tony  /  29
Dingle, Mary  /  118
Fellman,  Jill  /  144
Ferdig,  Richard E.  /  171
Fiszer,  Edward  /  128
Fleres,  Carol  -  108
Garbett,   Dawn  /  103
George, Camille  /  61
Gercek,  Gokhan  /  209
Gibson,  Shanan  /  160
Harris,  Michael  /  160
Juhary, Jowati  /  204
Kamuche, Felix U.  /  45
Kang, Rui  /  123
Khan,  Lorrinda  /  219
Lai,  Horng-Ji  /  150
Lamkin,  Marcia  /  198
Lockhart, Marilyn  /   14
Lynn, Vivian  /  219
Marcketti,  Sara B.  /  182
Matthews-Somerville, Rochelle  /  214
McGunagle,  Doreen  /  219
McLean, Jennifer  /  176
Miller,  William  /  219
Mitchell, Deborah C.  /  78
Moskal,   Barbara M.  /  144
Mueller,  Suzanne S.  /  50
Murawski,  Wendy W.  /  113
Nardone,  Carroll Ferguson   /   19
Neely,  Glenda  /  91
Norton, Sue Margaret   /   8
Palka, Jacqueline  /  97
Paul,   Mark  /  91
Pierson, Melinda R.  /  138
Pinciotti,  Patricia  /  50
Pitton, Debra Eckerman  /  84
Pryor,  Caroline  /  123
Richmond,  Aaron S.  /  29
Saleem, Naveed  /  209
Saleh, Amany  /  198
Shams, Ashley  /  61
Smeaton,  Patricia S.  /  50
Snelson,  Chareen  /  155
Sosin, Adrienne Andi  /  68
Su, Shau – E Eve  /  187
Tichenor, Mercedes  /  97
Tynan-Yourn, Belinda  /  103
Ulmer,, M. B.  /   24
Waters,  Faith H.  /  50
Wickersham,  Leah E.  /  187
Wood,   Meg VB  / 166
Xiao,   Judy  /  56
Yurchisin, Jennifer  /  182